DEAR STREET CARNAGE: WHY NATIVE NEW YORKERS HATE TRANSPLANTS
Let me just start this by saying I have nothing against transplants — although I’ve noticed that you migrants and post-collegiates constantly berate me and my Yankee compadres with tirades about how much moving to NYC meant to you or how we need to appreciate our good fortune. You seem to have this chip on your shoulder, and I thought maybe I could shed some light on our side of the fence. Here are some things that bring out New Yorkers’ alleged callousness towards transplants: YOU HAVE NOTHING TO LOSE YOU CARE ABOUT SHIT YOU’RE RICH AND WON’T ADMIT IT WE’RE RICH AND WON’T ADMIT IT NATIVES BOTHER THE SHIT OUT OF US MORE THAN YOU YOU HATE PEOPLE FROM OUT OF TOWN YOU TALK ABOUT HOW YOUR HOMETOWN IS LESS RACIST THAN NEW YORK YOU LOVE TO TRY POMME FRITES YOU HATE GRAFFITI YOU TELL US NOT TO LITTER YOU TELL US WE SWEAR TOO MUCH YOU GENTRIFY POOR NEIGHBORHOOD (AND LIKE IT) You have to admit that part of you loves living in the “dangerous” (i.e. ethnic) part of New York. And you know that if you keep it, it will be worth double in ten years. You screwed the pooch on a pretty sweet deal. Young Puerto Ricans were paying $200 a month for duplexes, as basically their main “fuck you” to the system — and now you don’t even smile when they cat call you. The worst part is that Bed-Stuy isn’t even all poor, it’s just cheaper and black, which translates to “tough” for a lot of you. YOU WANT NEW YORK TO CATER TO YOU YOU INSIST ON GOING TO FAMILIAR CHAINS YOU TREAT US AS IF WE’RE STREET-SAVVY SWAMIS WE’VE DONE THIS A MILLION TIMES ALREADY YOU SAY “IT AIN’T WHERE YOU’RE FROM, IT’S WHERE YOU’RE AT” YOU PISSED ON MY MOM’S FRONT DOOR Like it or not, we’re all going to be living here together until we die or move. And if you don’t move, soon enough you’ll have your own little asshole native kid, bragging about 2012 like it was the good old days. Sincerely, Send “Dear Street Carnage” letters to SBTVC@StreetCarnage.com.
Kicking in a windshield is fun, no question. But for us, to do so means we might run into a family friend knee-deep in safety glass. You guys are essentially on permanent vacation. We deal with all the same bullshit of any hometown — just neatly numbered and divided into little rectangles. We have no escape plan. If shit goes down, I can’t hop on a plane and just kick it with mom and dad for two weeks downloading porn.
We couldn’t give a fuck about a bike lane or a new taxi design. These things happen every day. Buildings come and go and it can be sad, but we’re used to it and you will be soon. Domino sugar factory will be torn down or turned into condos and somehow people will be mad either way. We just don’t understand the need to talk about it. The only thing that bothers me is the cost of pizza rising, and it bothers me so little that this is the first time I’ve ever thought of it.
You can wax profusely about your parents not sending you a cent and how you slave away at some awful vintage-something store, but we all know your parents are doing fine. Moving state to state is incredibly expensive, and the only thing that makes it more expensive is college. Even on a full scholarship, you’re going to need some serious start-up cash. I’m from a single-parent household, living on and off of unemployment. I attended high schools that consistently made NY POST headlines, and guess what? I’m not poor and never was. Now and then people fall on hard times, but there’s a reason Biggie said, “Remember when we used to eat sardines for dinner?”
Any young adult you’ve met living in New York is rich. Angry natives who “hate the trust fund NYU kids” have parents even richer than yours. They might know a good bar that doesn’t card and they’ll tell you about that time on 86th street when a bunch of other private schoolers chased them with a knife. But these kind of situations present themselves to anyone who has lived in a major city long enough. Natives used these stories to build up an “old New York” that never really was, mostly just to contend with the old guys who actually lived in the Taxi Driver era.
What’s more annoying than a 60-year-old talking to you about the “good old days?” Having him speak to you for an extra 20-minutes because you arbitrarily were reared in the same fucking place.
“Go back to Jersey!” is something I only hear shouted by transplants. At least the Jersey crowd goes home on Sunday. Shouting that shit only makes us remember that you are the rent-raisers here. The truth is, most natives really don’t have a problem with you guys until you start to really claim New York residency as some badge of honor. How long we’ve lived here never crosses our minds, but if you make it a pissing contest, we will always win.
Jesus, it would take at least three hands to count how many times someone has explained to me that New York is more racist than the South, the Midwest, Canada, Hamburg, Sweden — I DON’T CARE AT ALL. What is this supposed to prove to me? That I’m racist? Is this your idea of making a friend? Baffling.
It’s a sack of french fries for $8.75. C’mon….
My one and only argument about graffiti is “Who gives a shit?” If you answered “me,” then you lose. You don’t care. It’s not your building and you don’t ever have to paint it over. Even in the rare case that a SBTVC reader actually owns a building, I guarantee you that they’ll appreciate having to actually go out and do some remedial thing like painting a storm gate. Almost every “Epic Night Out” story I hear involves medium to severe property damage and some vomit / piss spillage. Then a 15-year-old writes “TrazEe” with a magic marker on a mailbox and suddenly everyone gives a shit about “beautification.” What no one seems to understand is that graffiti is for nerds who can’t play guitar or rap (i.e. get pussy without being rich). Graffiti is easier than getting on Real World and throws the bad boy image into a blender with the mysterious stranger vibe. Girls love it, and it works like a fucking charm.
Why anyone gives a fuck about an apple core being thrown into the street will never cease to amaze me. It’s not a national park where you carry out what you bring in. The city is cleaned according to the sanitation department’s schedule and budget. Little known fact: A staggering amount of lower Manhattan is a fucking landfill. Throwing a candy wrapper on cement is not melting any icecaps.
Basically the same thing as the last two: Who cares? I’m not really going to explain it. We just say “fuckin’” and “shit” instead of “um” and “like” because it’s more fun.
This really only applies to the residents of neighborhoods mentioned in rap songs, discounting any new Jay-Z joints. But come on: I’ve lived in Manhattan my whole life besides two years in Greenpoint (in diapers). It’s stupid easy to find apartments for any price. On average, I’ve paid around $700 a month to live in lower Manhattan. Bed-Stuy and Bushwick are NOT your only option.
Newsflash! It already does. Macrobiotic food may not be in your five-block radius, but it’s out there. Why then is it necessary to open a food co-op on Morgan Ave? Do you really think that the residents of that neighborhood are grateful? A food co-op is basically a burning cross for any person living in the ghetto (excuse me, “underprivileged community”); they know they can either leave now or wait until the landlord condemns their building, then rebuilds it as a condo (this happens a lot, BTW). What’s worse is, the next thing you know, your Bushwick fried chicken place suddenly has organic fruit smoothies. Doesn’t that make you cringe a bit?
I don’t boycott these places for any reason other than they make shitty things and have bad service. However, you now live the most famous place on the world for EVERYTHING and you still go to Papa Johns and Walgreens? Occupiers of Wall Street claim all this 99% shit and then pour into Burger King — or worse, they bring their own metal water bottles and celery sticks. Meanwhile Steve’s Pizza is losing business.
We don’t know shit. If you have a map of NYC, then you already know more than me. I have nothing interesting to tell you about growing up on pavement versus growing up on grass.
This one is probably the most by hated by transplants but that doesn’t make it untrue. I don’t feel like listing the things I’ve done because it’s boring me to even think about it. But that’s my point: I have had only a quarter of a century of shit happen to me and I’m already exhausted just thinking about it. More importantly, I have heard thousands of stories from hundreds of people who have lived here for upwards of six decades. I can’t imagine you had a night more exciting than the one I heard about from an ex-gangbanger-now-tranny. The funny thing is, tell me a good story about trucks and cornfields and there’s a good chance I’ll be genuinely captivated.
I call bullshit on this. Yoko Ono has lived here for what, 60 years? And she still talks all FOB-y. There’s a reason people keep their accents and mannerisms: It’s who they are. I’m a big nurture over nature guy, but you have to be nurtured somewhere. While you may be the sore thumb in the family photo, your hometown is where you learned to become a human being. You’re probably a better person for not growing up in this place.
My mom lives in the East Village, which is to say she lives “on campus”. She has rent control and she isn’t going to move out of her $500-a-month apartment because a bunch of freshmen live next door. (Seriously, would you?) She’s not bitter and doesn’t mind it. But just picture this: You leave dinner at your mom’s house in Suburbia, USA, walk out on your lawn, and a dude wearing a “TWIX” logo T-shirt pisses all over your shoes. Seriously, I had that happen to me. I just went with it, ’cause if I have a problem, then I’m just some crotchety, stuck-up native type.
—
-W




















